‘Fake News Victims’ Meet With Twitter and Facebook

Journalist: Issie Lapowsky

Source Link: Wired

On paper, they would seem to have little in common. Tun Khin is a human rights activist who advocates for the persecuted Rohingya Muslims in his home country of Myanmar. Jessikka Aro is a Finnish journalist who exposed the international influence of Russian propagandists at the Internet Research Agency long before the rest of the world had ever heard of them. Lenny Pozner is an American father who lost his 6-year-old son, Noah, in the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary in 2012. Ethan Lindenberger is almost a kid himself, a high school student who’s become a vaccination proponent despite his parents’ anti-vaccination beliefs.

But all four of them are bound by one unfortunate and common thread: They’ve all seen firsthand just how ugly—and downright dangerous—the spread of fake news and disinformation online can be. Which is why this week, they gathered in Silicon Valley to talk with tech executives about what they’ve been through and what they want tech companies to do about it. The group met with Twitter on Tuesday, and another meeting was planned at Facebook Wednesday afternoon.

The meetings, which were organized by a nonprofit advocacy group called Avaaz, come at a time of fierce debate over what responsibility tech companies have to limit the spread of toxic content on their platforms. Just last week, Facebook announced it was banning seven people, including Infowars conspiracy theorists Alex Jones and Paul Joseph Watson, under a policy that prohibits “dangerous individuals” from having any presence on Facebook. The bans prompted President Trump to lash out against tech companies over the weekend, ramping up accusations of censorship that have become a constant drumbeat on the right.

The discussions organized by Avaaz served as a counterpoint to all that pressure, as individual victims of online harassment campaigns came forward to tell tech companies exactly how they’ve been hurt by the hate and hoaxes that have festered on their platforms. “Our job as advocates is to make them stop for a minute and think about the implications of not acting fast enough,” says Oscar Soria, a senior campaigner with Avaaz.

During Tuesday’s meeting with Twitter, the attendees took turns telling their stories. Aro shared the details of the global smear campaign that was lodged against her, after her reporting outed the Internet Research Agency. She explained the threats that have been made against her life and read a recent direct message she received while traveling in the Czech Republic, in which a stranger threatened to “castrate” her if she ever came back to the country.

Aro says the harassment she’s received violates Finnish defamation laws, and she is in the process of pursuing cases against some of her harassers in court. And yet, she says, the complaints she’s filed to Twitter and Facebook often go unanswered, leaving local investigators to do the work the American companies won’t. “I’m basically here, to put it simply, to give a user report live, because they haven’t reacted to the ones that I have made online,” Aro says.

Khin described the trauma he’s seen in Rohingya refugee camps and pressed Twitter about why it continues to provide safe haven for Senior General Min Aung Hlaing, the commander-in-chief of the Myanmar military. The military was behind some of the accounts that notoriously flooded Facebook with anti-Islam rhetoric, and the United Nations called for its leaders to face genocide charges last year. Facebook has since banned Min Aung Hlaing and other accounts and pages that the UN linked to human rights abuses in the country. While the general’s Twitter account hasn’t been active since last year, it remains up on the platform today.

“He was the mastermind of the Rohingya genocide. The UN has said he was personally responsible. And Facebook has already banned him. What more evidence do they need?” Khin wrote in a tweet following the meeting.

Lindenberger, meanwhile, discussed how his parents came to believe anti-vaccination propaganda on social media, leaving him and his siblings exposed to potentially deadly viruses like the measles. According to Soria, Lindenberger told Twitter executives that after he testified about this issue before the Senate, he himself became the subject of a disinformation campaign. Recently, he said, his own pastor told him to avoid church for his own protection. (WIRED wasn’t able to reach Lindenberger.)

Pozner, for his part, has faced such violent threats that he is participating in the meetings remotely. Ever since the Sandy Hook tragedy took his son’s life, Pozner and his family have been forced to live in hiding, hounded by online death threats from people who believe that the shooting was a hoax. The conspiracy theory, propagated by figures like Alex Jones, has no basis in reality.

Now, Pozner runs a non-profit called HONR Network aimed at ending online harassment campaigns, helping its victims, and working with tech companies to change their policies. Of all the tech platforms, Pozner says, Twitter has the farthest to go in terms of cracking down on hoaxes and harassment. “Twitter has allowed their platform to be used as a weapon of mass destruction for which they must take accountability,” he says.

Twitter spokesperson Liz Kelley told WIRED that the conversation on Tuesday centered on how Twitter can prohibit the “manipulation of the conversation, not serving as the arbiters of truth,” and how Twitter is enforcing the policies against hate speech and violent threats that are already in place. “Hearing these stories is a valuable way for us to inform our decisions and product investments going forward,” Kelley said.

Facebook confirmed its executives met with the group, but declined to offer further comment. Avaaz’s organizers also hoped to meet with executives from Google, whose video platform YouTube has helped promote some of the internet’s worst conspiracies. As of Wednesday afternoon, a meeting with Google had not yet been scheduled.

In addition to giving the group a chance to share their stories, Avaaz also encouraged Facebook and Twitter to adopt a policy that would alert people when they’ve been exposed to information marked false by third-party fact-checkers. Facebook has taken steps to expand fact-checking on its platform, recently announcing that it will limit the visibility of groups that repeatedly share content marked as false by fact-checkers. And just this week the company announced that fact-checkers will also begin vetting information on Instagram. Avaaz wants to see Twitter adopt its own fact-checking policy and to see Facebook build upon the one that’s already in place.

“This is a necessary step to restore public trust,” Soria says.

Social media companies have been historically reluctant to make such editorial decisions on their platforms. And, given the recent heightened accusations of liberal bias in Silicon Valley, including from the President of the United States, making decisions about who is right and wrong on the internet comes with risks for these companies. Pozner just hopes these meetings will underscore the fact that the risks he and other victims have faced are so much greater.

“I am a strong proponent of the First Amendment, and free speech is an essential aspect of American society. However, there is a fundamental misunderstanding of people’s rights and responsibilities online,” Pozner says. “A person cannot violate my civil rights to be free of harassment, bullying, or to have my likeness manipulated and my family targeted with death threats and intimidation and then simply attempt to hide behind ‘free speech.'”

lenny-shadow.jpg
‘Fake news victims’ meet with Facebook, Twitter, YouTube
Journalist: Levi Sumagaysay
Source Link: Mercury News
People who have been harmed by “fake news” appealed to executives at Facebook and Twitter and urged them to do more to stop the spread of disinformation during what they said were emotional, face-to-face meetings this week.
Finnish journalist Jessikka Aro said she has been harassed and threatened ever since she visited St. Petersburg in 2015 to investigate the Internet Research Agency, the Russian troll farm whose members were indicted by the U.S. Department of Justice in February on charges of using social media to interfere with U.S. elections.
“My life has been destroyed after I started to investigate Russian information warfare,” Aro said during a news conference in San Francisco on Thursday. “I have been forced to move abroad.”
She said the harassment, which continues despite some of the perpetrators being sent to prison, also is on YouTube. Aro and the rest of the group are scheduled to meet with Google and YouTube Thursday.
“It’s madness,” she said, her voice cracking as she appeared to hold back tears.
One member of the group is a Rohingya human rights activist from Myanmar who briefs governments around the world on human rights violations committed against Rohingya Muslims. Myanmar’s military, accused of ethnic cleansing, has driven nearly 1 million of the minority Rohingya people out of that country since 2017, according to Human Rights Watch.
“We would like to see urgency from social media companies,” said Tun Khin, who fled Myanmar but has met with people who have lost their families and homes there. “This is genocide we are talking about. We need action.” His voice got louder and he appeared to get agitated as he talked about Myanmar soldiers posting racist content on Facebook, and how it has taken the company years to pay attention.
Avaaz, an advocacy group that’s working to fight disinformation around the world, facilitated the meetings with the tech companies. Fadi Quran, campaign director for Avaaz, said Thursday that the group agreed to honor the tech companies’ requests that any specific action being considered be kept confidential for now, but that “We’re going to give them a three-month deadline to implement steps promised at the meetings.”
One of the solutions Avaaz is pushing for — which it mentioned in an open letter asking to meet with the chief executives of Facebook, Twitter, Google and YouTube — is for the companies to implement a correction policy similar to what news organizations have.
“How much more pain, death and suffering will it take for you to clean up your social platforms and defend us all against disinformation?” asks the letter, which was signed by seven victims of disinformation.
Facebook said it would have no comment. Twitter said Thursday that hearing the stories was valuable and would help inform its decisions, but would not disclose which executives were present at the meeting.
Underscoring the dangers of hatred enabled by online platforms, one of the members of the group who did not appear at the news conference spoke to reporters over the phone.
Lenny Pozner is the father of Noah, a 6-year-old killed in the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in 2012. Pozner is one of the Sandy Hook parents suing Alex Jones, the InfoWars media personality who helped fuel a conspiracy theory that the shooting that killed 26 children and educators was a hoax. (Facebook last week banned Jones along with other controversial figures; Twitter, Apple and YouTube banned him last year.)
“I’ve been put into the position where I can’t just do nothing about this denial of my son’s life and death, and the denial of my pain,” said Pozner, who said he has been forced to move eight times because he has become a target of conspiracy theorists. “I’ve worked hard to have an impact on online disinformation… I look forward to the day when I can quietly grieve the loss of my child. But for now we need to fight and bring more awareness to this very real problem.”
Ethan Lindenberger, an 18-year-old high school student, traveled to the Bay Area from Ohio to meet with the tech giants. He and his siblings were not vaccinated by his parents, and he has testified to U.S. senators that his mother received most of her anti-vaccination disinformation on Facebook.
Lindenberger said the tech executives appeared to be moved by the stories the group shared.
“We only hope that they turn those emotions to action,” he said. “I hope they understand this is an issue that can’t be solved just with algorithms.”
Avaaz’s Quran said the companies have promised to investigate the specific cases they heard about this week. The advocacy group’s other work has included fighting disinformation around elections in Brazil and Spain. One of its most visible campaigns is the traveling cardboard cutouts of Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, which have been seen at protests in Washington, D.C., as well as the European Union headquarters in Brussels.

Categories

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe

Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates.

We respect your privacy.